IMPOSSIBLE TO LOVE THIS BOOK!
When I picked up a copy of IMPOSSIBLE, I was excited to read it. A National Book Award finalist, it had all of the elements of a potential favorite–a story inspired by song, a mysterious curse, a strong female protagonist who would have to survive an act of violence.
Werlin wove her tale around the lyrics of the legendary song “Scarborough Fair,” and the mystery she created was indeed initially intriguing. Lucy, a 17-year-old, is the victim of a date rape (which is in no way described in the novel) and becomes pregnant. As Lucy was born to a 17-year-old unwed mother, the mystery begins as history seemingly repeats itself. She investigates, and with the help of her friend (who becomes a love interest) and foster parents, Lucy learns that five generations of women in her family have been unwed and impregnated at the age of seventeen. What’s even more disturbing is that each her ancestors lost her mind after giving birth. Ultimately, Lucy must perform seemingly impossible tasks as they are outlined in alternative lyrics of “Scarborough Fair” (one of which is to make a shirt with no seams), if she is to escape the curse. There is a level of suspense in the story, as readers wonder if Lucy will survive the ordeal and live happily ever after.
This book has a magical element to it (with the Elfin Knight as the antagonist), but it falls short of fantasy. Harry Potter fans won’t like it, as the writing style isn’t as lyrical. The reading level is quite easy, making it a quick read for any teen or adult. However, the story is somewhat unsatisfying, and the subject matter may be too mature for some preteens. I was hoping for a new teen favorite; instead, I encountered an okay story with some interesting allusions to legend. There are a few poetic passages, but most of the book is driven by basic narrative that doesn’t resonate once the book is closed.
